If you read the news today, all you will see are headlines proclaiming that GDP contracted by 3.8% in 4Q08. Here are some of the headlines I’ve found:
- “Q4 GDP down 3.8%, biggest drop since 1982″ – Yahoo.com
- “US GDP shrank 3.8% last quarter, most since 1982″ – Bloomberg
- “Economy: Sharpest decline in 26 years” – CnnMoney.com
- “Obama addresses new numbers showing shrinking U.S. economy, calls for Senate to back stimulus” – Foxnews.com
- “GDP shrinks as spending falls” – Wall Street Journal Online
The list goes on and you get the picture. It just goes to show how negative the news media is today. Not one of these news venues thought to highlight the fact that our 4Q08 GDP figure beat the economists estimates by 30%! Can that be right? Yep, the 79 of smartest minds in the dismal science projected that the US would contract in the 4th quarter by 5.5%. In reality, we only contracted by 3.8% in 4Q08. In the Bloomberg article, you have to go down 31 lines before they mention that we beat the forecast.
Another point that gets lost in the negativity is that the United States economy grew in 2008. Let me say that again, the United States economy grew in 2008. For 2008, the US GDP grew by 1.3%. Now, that’s not a huge growth number and pales in comparison to China’s 8% growth, but it is still growth. It’s like getting a smaller than expected raise. Yes, it stings, but it is far better than getting a pay cut. However, you have to go down to line 41 before the same Bloomberg article mentions the growth. They then go on to explain what contributed to the growth – exports and the Bush administration’s tax rebates (although Bush is not mentioned by name). So, people are still buying American products and tax cuts were effective at boosting GDP. Those are two very interesting points as we ponder a $900 billion stimulus plan.
There is no doubt that the US economy is hurting. However, consumer sentiment is largely to blame for the decrease in consumer spending. If all consumers hear about is negative news, changing consumer sentiment will be a long, tedious process. There are some that would argue that Washington wants to portray a doomsday scenario and instill fear into the American psyche so they can garner support for the stimulus bill. Regardless of whether you subscribe to that theory, America needs a healthy shot of optimism and today’s economic numbers could help out. However, you have to read through some doom and gloom to find anything positive.

