The Navy this week announced that it has decided to home port a carrier at Naval Station Mayport in Florida.  Currently, the entire carrier fleet is stationed at Naval facilities in Hampton Roads.  The Navy’s motivation behind the move is to diversify the fleet and prevent a Pearl Harbour type incident from diminishing our retaliatory abilities.

The decision was met with significant opposition from Virginia lawmakers who vow to continue the fight to keep the carrier fleet in Virginia.  They claim that this is a politically motivated last minute effort by the Bush administration to push this through before they leave the office.  Consequently, they have begun to pressure the incoming Obama administration to reconsider the decision.  As you would expect, Florida lawmakers support the decision and call it critical to the security of America.

To compound the issue, the decision comes at a time when the Naval has its own budgetary issues to contend with and moving a carrier isn’t cheap.  In the five years that it will take to complete the move, the Navy would have to spend over $550 million to prepare the Mayport facility and channel for a ship of this size.  In addition, it will remove 11,000 jobs and $600 million in annual income from the Hampton Roads economy.

If the safety of the fleet is truly the primary concern, I would think the $550 million could buy some significant surface to air defenses for the Hampton Roads area.  Plus, any spending on protecting the fleet in its current location could be allocated across the entire fleet, not just one carrier.